Ben,
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I think you gave a perfect answer to my question. I figured it had to be some detail about material or construction… even though I know it’s sometimes difficult to describe exactly why one product feels better than another.

Jay,
Thanks so much for the comment. My opinion is based mainly on handling both the Fishpond and the W&M cases. In my opinion, I think the Fishpond case is a bit stouter material along with with a waterproof bottom and a bit more padding. I like the extra external pocket, and I prefer the mesh pockets on the inside vs. the plastic pocket on the inside of the W&M. I think the shoulder strap on the Fishpond is nicer and higher quality material and padding. I took a look at the Simms reel case as well and liked the extra pockets and construction of the bag, but ultimately narrowed my search to the Fishpond and the W&M briefcases.

As with all my reviews I try to provide my honest opinion, whether I am provided the product by the manufacturer to test, or I purchase the item with my own hard earned money, as is the case with the W&M case. Bottom line, I really do like the W&M case and feel that for the money it is the best deal on the market. I have recommended this bag to several friends over the Fishpond, because I don’t believe the extra frills are worth the money on a reel bag. I did my own personal research before spending my money, and knew what I was buying. I know it will last me for many years and will serve its purpose well.

I hope that clarifies what I meant and that you understand that I wasn’t trying to take a shot at a friend. Take care.

Ben